The War & Treaty- The Story of Michael & Tanya
Label: Atlantic
Producer: Buddy Miller
As the present decade dawned, and one the strength of their outstanding first two albums, The War & Treaty boldly emerged as one of the Americana scene’s most vibrant new creative forces. Their luminous husband-wife harmonies, anchored by their respectively soaring vocal ranges, and their richly rewarding and expansive blend of classic American genres quickly cast Michael Trotter Jr. and Tanya Trotter collectively as one of the most buzz-worthy acts, both in the Americana sphere, and well beyond the fringes into the mainstream. In the past half-decade, they’ve become one of the most in-demand collaborative acts, sharing the studio and stage with a diverse range of artists including Emmylou Harris, Zach Bryan, Bon Jovi, Al Green, Jason Isbell, Brandi Carlile, Josh Groban, Dierks Bentley, Brothers Osborne, Nitty Gritty Dirt Band, and Shania Twain. And while their music could never be contained to one specific genre, country music’s place as a central pillar in their sound eventually transplanted them in the heart of Nashville, culminating in a major record label deal with Universal Music in 2022.
Many feared this would be a classic Music City cautionary tale, where notorious Music Row commerciality would rob a resurgent act of their authenticity. Refreshingly, the first album that this deal birthed- 2023’s Lover’s Game, while certainly more polished, still felt natural and loyal to the couple’s artistic path to that point, while also landing their names on the ballots of both the CMA and Grammy Awards. Last year’s Plus One however found things quickly jumpin the shark sonically, making it clear that they were an act that was long for the mainstream game. So, it comes as no surprise that this new album finds them retreating to a new a label home and united with roots-godfather, Buddy Miller in the producer’s chair. In the promotional press leading up to The Story, the Trotters bluntly acknowledged dissatisfaction with the Nashville game, having felt artistically neutered on their major label releases, and proclaiming this LP as a course-correction.
It proves to be just that, and then some. Any mainstream chains plaguing the duo are passionately unshackled here, and it results in not only a return to the unlimited, soul-stirring tapestry of their original work, but also a palpable artistic exorcism; a rebirth and further evolution to brand new personal and artistic heights. The stage for this theme is directly set by none other than Whoopi Goldberg, who provides a wonderfully theatrical introduction, reaffirming the album’s own conceptual identity as a reclamation for the couple of their creative identities. This segues into “Litty”, the saucy and gorgeously rapturous opening number that follows the natural evolution of any romance; from sweet and innocently naive optimism, to one that is all the stronger for the gritty trials that crop up over time. Their golden voices are beautifully brandished here by soulful horns and vintage R&B spirit, qualities that carry through the soul-heavy opening arc of the record.
“You Can’t Hurt Me Anymore” marries drippy doo-wop riffs with lush and haunted steel, with the country-soul tinges giving Michael a prime showcase for his impressive growl. Things take a positively dark and spooky turn on the tantalizing “Shouldn’t Have”, which sounds like it came straight out of a late-sixties Stax studio session, between the sizzling guitar solos and the couple’s pristine soul stylings that just wrench every aching emotion out of each lyric and phrase. However, the most stunning centerpiece of this early sequence–and truthfully of the entire album itself- is certainly lead single, “Don’t Say Goodbye”, a sensuous R&B production that feels both vintage and revelatory all the same. This is Tanya’s greatest vocal moment to date, captivating with her ability to tap into a referential blend that recalls iconic songstresses like Aretha, Gladys, and Lauryn Hill in one brilliant swoop. Nevertheless, Michael does indeed match her intensity here, reminding listeners that its their union together that remains the central ingredient to their magical ability to express such evocative romance, longing, tension, and passion.
At this point in the album, the Trotters seamlessly transition into a trifecta that certainly serves as the most overtly country-influenced segment of the record, and with selections that are just as sumptuously hair-raising as their predecessors. “Darlene and Gene” is a sheer thriller, steeped in classic country storytelling themes of cheating and yes, murder. It finds Tanya delivering a fascinating narration dripping in Southern Gothic mystery, punctuated with a slithering soul spark and fetching bayou bewitchery. The girl-power remains amped up on “Reclaim All of Your Time”, a shuffling feministic anthem that unifies Trotter’s vintage twang with both Valerie June’s mystic spirit, and a towering appearance from Wynonna where the surviving Judd filters a throw-back Kitty Wells-twang through a spicy Wanda Jackson filter. That powerhouse conglomerate is intimidating to try and follow, but Michael does just that with “Lay This Bottle Down”, a slow, aching ballad of devastating demons that starts out as a bare-boned gospel plea, before painstakingly progressing into a honky-tonk-blues stunner.
The closing arc of the album raises the emotional stakes of the music even more, first with “Don’t Give Up Now”, a hushed yet powerful extension of love and support to a hurting lover. The juxtaposition of the bare emotions and the increasingly thunderous production hits a truthfully stirring sweet-spot. Conversely, “Holy Ghost” is sonically unflinching, a collision-course of gospel, rock, and soul where you can almost feel the heat of the flames they’re singing about. Finally, the album closes with “High Heels”, a ramshackle, R&B rabble-rouser that serves as perhaps the record’s most enticing evidence of the duo’s special chemistry, and certainly reveals itself as the album’s most anticipated addition to their much-acclaimed live repertoire. As the album wraps, you do become suddenly aware of how the overall mix of material occasionally subverts the seeming autobiographical expectations set by its title, and Goldberg’s initial intro. Many of these songs–particularly moments like “Darlene and Gene”–more than blur the lines between cinema and real life. Nevertheless, they’re all delivered with the same, impassioned sense of conviction, realism, and emotional impact. In the end, this fine line between biography and narration only elevates the enticing aura of the overall record.
In the end, it all equates to the most enthralling, authentic, and fully-formed chapter in the War & Treaty’s musical story thus far. This is a masterful musical statement and artistic achievement in every imaginable realm: vocally, thematically, musically, and stylistically. In terms of singing alone, it’s flat-out some of the very best you’ll find anywhere on record in 2026, and it’s supported by truly excellent material and musicianship. The Story of Michael & Tanya is the kind of unabashedly raw musical work that has always been uniquely special in popular music, but has become scarcely rare in today’s modern climate. For all the professional twists and turns of their recent years, it’s all led them to where they need to be with this record, and it’s a beautiful and triumphant place to be. A watershed moment, without question, and one that raises the stakes significantly for what’s next.
Track Listing:
- “Litty” with Whoopi Goldberg (Michael Trotter Jr., Tanya Trotter, Hamilton Hardin, Nicole Hardin)
- “Don’t Say Goodbye” (M. Trotter, T. Trotter)
- “You Can’t Hurt Me Anymore” (T. Trotter, Jon Randall, Jessi Alexander, Kenneth Edmonds, Jeff Gitelman)
- “Shouldn’t Have” (M. Trotter, T. Trotter)
- “Darlene and Gene” (M. Trotter, Zakk Garner)
- “Reclaim All Of Your Time” featuring Valerie June and Wynonna (M. Trotter, T. Trotter, Garner)
- “Lay This Bottle Down” (T. Trotter, Garner)
- “Don’t Give Up Now” (M. Trotter, T. Trotter)
- “Holy Ghost Fire” (M. Trotter, T. Trotter)
- “High Heels” (M. Trotter, T. Trotter, H. Hardin, N. Hardin)
The 706 
Leave a comment